The Power of the Underdog

The Power of the Underdog

By Duncan Foster

In August of last year I moved to the USA to play soccer for a small university in Tennessee. What we achieved as a team was more than any of us could have imagined, or even dreamt about whilst going through a brutal pre-season at the beginning of August. We under-achieved in our conference, lost in the quarterfinals of our conference tournament, and were not nationally ranked for the entire season. That was, until we scraped into the national championships, and won the next 6 games to end up in the national championship game, the battle to be crowned the best team in America in our division. Unfortunately we lost in the final, but our journey as the underdogs in all but the 1st round was pretty incredible; and we finished the season ranked #2 in America.

This is where our remarkable story begins.

We were expected to win our round 1 match, against the 5th seed in our region. However, from then on in, we were the significant underdogs.

  • • In round 2 we played the team ranked 1st in our region and 13th in the nation at their home pitch having played a game two days previously.
  • • In round 3 we played the team ranked 3rd in our region – who we lost against in pre-season.
  • • In the quarterfinals (southeast region final) we played the team ranked 4th in the nation at their home pitch.
  • • In the semifinals, we played a team ranked 12th in the nation.
  • • In the final we played the team that finished the regular season ranked 2nd in the nation and that had won 21 games in a row.

My question is how much did the status of the underdog in all of these matches boost our performance?

Wikipedia, although not a reliable source, quotes ‘A Cinderella Story’ to be “a team who advances much further in a tournament than expected, gaining much media and fan attention as they progress”. My team were this “Cinderella Team” throughout the entire tournament, and this ‘Cinderella Story’ was quoted numerous times, which the Brits on the team did not enjoy seeing as in the United Kingdom a ‘Cinderella Team’ is one that underachieves.

Throughout history, people love rooting for the underdog and seeing them succeed. Look at the success of the Rocky films. The underdog is often perceived as inferior to the opposition, maybe not as technically gifted or athletically gifted, and therefore the challenge to win is greater.

mens_soccer_celebrationThere has not been much written about the psychology behind being the underdog team, my belief is that it could be perceived a couple of ways. The first would be to see that you could just go out and enjoy the game and the occasion, as you won’t win the game. The other is that you should go out and give everything alongside your teammates and see what happens.  For my team, we went into every game believing that we could win the game, no matter what our perceived status was. We knew that with extreme hard work and effort that we had a chance, no matter who we were playing. We had nothing to lose from the game. There was no expectation to win the game; the pressure was on the “superior” team. This shared confidence in ourselves to upset the odds, combined with the selfless work rate on the field, was ultimately what pushed us through each round against perceived superior opposition.

Contrastingly, the psychology of the ‘superior team’ is interesting. Looking at a professional example in football is the FA Cup or League Cup in England. My team, Wycombe Wanderers, have reached the semi-finals in each of these competitions during my teenage years, despite struggling to make any sort of mark on their league status. During these runs, they have beaten then Premier League and Championship opposition – teams that are superior. When a team from the Premier League plays against League 2 (or even lower) opposition, they will not prepare entirely in the same way that they would if they were playing Manchester United or Chelsea. As much as the players think they will go through their match day routines the same way, subconsciously they will be cutting corners as the game is not perceived as much of a challenge to what they are used to. And on the flip side, the underdog will concentrate on every minute detail in order to perform optimally.

Underestimating your opponent and letting complacency into the team can be very detrimental for the stronger team. On many occasions, the superior talent will be enough to see off the challenge of the underdogs. However, there are many examples when this has not been the case, and this is why we, the spectators and fans, love sport so much – we love the unexpected victory, both as a fan, and as a neutral.

The extra work and team effort that is put in by the underdogs can be put down to “the desire for the underdog to overcome the inferior status and upset the favoured opponent“ (Frazier & Snyder, 1991).  The status of the opponents forces the underdog to undergo extra physical and mental preparation with an optimal focus for performance as a source of sport confidence and self-efficacy going into the match. (Vealey et al. 1998). The underdog teams should have extremely high motivation for the game, both intrinsic and extrinsic. Intrinsic motivation is defined as doing an activity for its inherent satisfactions (Ryan & Deci, 2000), so in the underdog case, to prove to themselves that they can compete with the higher calibre opposition.  Extrinsic motivation pertains that an activity is done in order to attain some separable outcome (Ryan & Deci, 2000), so as to prove to everybody else that they can compete at that level. However, as we progressed further in the national championship, the goal of winning the tournament became more and more within reach, and lifting the trophy became an extrinsic motivation, rather than just winning the next game.

For me, the motivation of beating a team classed as superior than you, combined with the extra physical work, and mental preparation going into the match made the difference in our matches. The superior team is always expected to win comfortably, but a hint of complacency on their part can be a huge downfall, as they could be outworked by the underdog. The difference in technical and athletic ability will be greater in the professional game, as opposed to the college game, but the concepts remain similar. In the cup competitions in England, there are always some shocks as the underdogs progress, and that’s why the FA Cup especially is so famous around the world.

Ultimately, a game of football is two sides of 11 players playing a match on a given day in certain conditions. The majority of the time, the perceived superior team will win the match, as their technical, tactical and athletic ability outweighs the effort put in by the inferior team. But for those occasions when it doesn’t, and the underdog prevails, I challenge you to find a better feeling than when your team wins.

“Hard work beats talent when talent doesn’t work hard” – Tim Notke


S² Tip

The majority of the time, the perceived superior team will win the match, as their technical, tactical and athletic ability outweighs the effort put in by the inferior team. But for those occasions when it doesn’t, and the underdog prevails, I challenge you to find a better feeling than when your team wins.


Success Story

Congratulations to Troy Tulowitzki for being put on the June issue of Sports Illustrated for the first time! Troy has been the best player in baseball for the first two months with a .521 average at home and a WAR of 4.6, putting him on record setting pace to smash the WAR of 11.9 previously set by Barry bonds. Tulowitzki has had to overcome numerous devastating injuries in his career, and is finally back on top as one of baseball’s greatest players.


In Another’s Words…

It’s part of life to have obstacles. It’s about overcoming obstacles; that’s the key to happiness.

– Herbie Hancock (Musician)